A Few Odds and Ends

I’ve already managed to put up a couple of reviews this month (which constitutes a good month at the moment!), so I thought I’d continue my weekly trend, this time with bite-size reviewettes of the other books I’ve got through in May so far.  Shall we?
Let’s start with a Nobel prize winner (just because)Orhan Pamuk’s My Name is Red (translated by Erdag Göknar) is a mystery set in sixteenth-century Istanbul, involving the beautiful, but fading art of traditional Arabic ‘illumination’ of literary texts.  One of a group of four master artists has been been murdered,  presumably by one of the other three, and Black, recently returned from a long absence in the East, is charged with finding the guilty culprit.  If he can win the hand of the beautiful Shekure along the way, so much the better 🙂
The novel consists of many chapters, each having its own voice, told by one of the characters (or a drawing…).  It’s an interesting way to tell a story, especially as the murderer actually has two voices – his real character, and that of ‘the Murderer’.  It makes for an intriguing tale, but I didn’t really love this book.  I was never really able to lose myself in the story, partly because of the, at times, slow pace, but perhaps more due to the unfamiliar setting which (to be honest) didn’t really interest me that much.  As a tale of masters of a dying art form struggling to cope with the inevitable overthrow of their way of life, it is a fascinating story – I’ll need another example of Pamuk’s work before I can really say whether I like his style though.
The Setting Sun by Osamu Dazai (translated by Donald Keene) is, as I’m sure you can guess, a little more in my line.  A fairly short novel, it tells the tale of Kazuko and her family, Japanese minor nobility who have descended in the world following the death of the father, and the financial strains caused by the aftermath of the Second World War.  Kazuko and her mother move away from Tokyo in order to stretch out their meagre reserves, but their lives are turned upside down again by the arrival of Kazuko’s brother Naoji, believed lost in the Pacific War.  Far from this being a happy family reunion, however, it is merely the start of a final freefall into poverty and distress.

I’ve read a lot of Japanese fiction over the past few years, but most of it has been set either before or after WWII, and I have the feeling that there isn’t as much literature dealing with this time as is the case in Germany (where it’s virtually its own genre…).  While it’s possible that I just haven’t found these books yet, even Mishima’s The Sea of Fertility Tetralogy, which spans fifty years between 1920 and 1970, conveniently skips the war years completely.  The Setting Sun then is a welcome insight into post-war Japan and the problems people had in adjusting to a new style of life and government.  The old aristocracy has lost its importance, the Emperor is not longer a deity, and Americans roam the streets of the conquered people (albeit very much in the background).

This leaves people like Kazuko and Naoji with a lot to work through if they want to carry on with their lives, and, in Japanese literature, that ‘if’ is never a given.  A quick glance at Dazai’s Wikipedia page will soon give you an idea of his, shall we say, lack of optimism for the future, a sense of negativity which is shared by his protagonists.  It all makes for an interesting slice of Japanese social history and a very entertaining read – just don’t expect many happy endings here…


A while back, I read Andrew McGahan’s 1988 and was impressed enough to make a library request for Praise (written before 1988 but set after), where we meet Gordon on his return to Brisbane.  Fed up with his job, he uses a management reshuffle as an excuse to quit, sinking gently into the bludger lifestyle of drink, drugs and trips to Centrelink.  Still paranoid about his lack of sexual prowess, he somehow slips into a relationship with Cynthia, whose appetite for bedroom activities far outstrips his.  When she decides to forgo a move to Darwin to give their nascent relationship a chance, Gordon isn’t entirely sure that it’s for the best – especially as his high school crush Rachel is back on the scene…

Praise reminds me a little of Helen Garner’s Monkey Grip, and could be seen as making a similar account of early-nineties Brisbane to the one Garner’s novel made of mid-seventies Melbourne.  I’d have to say though that it doesn’t do it nearly as well.  I liked 1988, with its subtle, psychological undertones, a story of a city boy stuck in the middle of nowhere and forced to face up to his inadequacies.  On the other hand, Praise just felt like a detailed list of one person’s sexual exploits and drug-fuelled indiscretions over a particularly unproductive period of his life.  I got through it fairly quickly, and, although I enjoyed reading it, I was happy to move onto something else – and not much of the book has stuck in my mind.

McGahan went on to win the Miles Franklin award with The White Earth (which I’m planning to read at some point), so I trust that his later books are more similar in vein to 1988 than Praise.  I know it sounds like I really hated this book, but that’s not the case; it’s just that I was expecting something very different – a progression, both in character and writing – to what I found.  I forgot that what I was reading actually predated what I’d previously read…

Has anyone else read this – and do you have a different opinion?  Please let me know 🙂

10 thoughts on “A Few Odds and Ends

  1. The Setting Sun looks suitably melancholic. I still haven't read any more Dazai after No Longer Human but am planning to at some point.

    I did try and read My Name is Red after a friend recommended it but I couldn't get past the first few pages so have opted to return to it one day. The premise sounded really interesting as it's a mystery set in a world I'm unfamiliar with.

    Talking about Japanese fiction set during and just after WWII, you're right in that there doesn't seem to be much written by Japanese authors set during this period. But have you read David Peace's Tokyo Year Zero? It's disturbing and uncomfortable reading but quite brilliant.


  2. Everyone says Pamuk's books are hard work. I'm now very intrigued especially coming from a revered literature critic like yourself!

    I have “My Name is Red” and “Snow” on my shelf. Perhaps I need to get going with his books to see how I feel about it. Maybe not at this moment, still recovering from a reading slump.

    Thanks for the beautiful review.


  3. Man of la Book – No worries 🙂 I plan to read 'The Museum of Innocence' soon, so I hope that will be even better!

    Sakura – I'm still looking for more from this era – none from Mishima and Kawabata that I'm aware of. I hadn't heard of the Pearce book, so I'll have to check it out 🙂

    JoV – This was my first Pamuk, and it was hard work – I didn't really feel a 'flow', and it dragged at times. However, there was enough there to make me want to try something else of his.

    Not the thing to try if you're in a reading slump though!


  4. The White Earth doesn't sound much like Praise or 1988. Its not an urban novel for a start, it is set West of the Blue Mountains, and is really concerned with the claim of white settlers to own the land. It works very well as a novel, quite unsettling in fact.


  5. I've been window shopping Pamuk's My Name is Red for some time now. The synopsis has always intrigued me but I will perhaps just be careful picking my timing/mood for it, given your experience. Cheers.


  6. Thanks for stopping by 🙂

    You were obviously happier with it than I was! I think 'My Name is Red' was the wrong one for me as I didn't feel a great interest in the subject matter. I still haven't followed up with Pamuk(!), but I would like to try something a little more contemporary, either 'The Museum of Innocence' or 'Snow'.


Every comment left on my blog helps a fairy find its wings, so please be generous - do it for the fairies.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.