The Wings Of An Angel

Last year, I never got around to participating in Dutch Lit Month, run by Iris of Iris On Books, so I was determined to take part this time.  Sadly, with one thing or another, June has turned out to be rather busy, so I’m afraid that all I have to offer is this one almost belated effort.  Still, it’s the thought that counts, right?

Cees Nooteboom is the one name which keeps coming up when people talk about Dutch literature, so I looked him up on my local library database and was lucky enough to reserve a copy of a recent novella, Lost Paradise (translated by Susan Massotty).  It’s a slight work, running to 150 sparsely-filled pages, with two main strands, connected late in the book by a surprising reunion – and by the writer’s insistence on putting himself in the story…

In the first part, we meet Alma, a young Brazilian woman full of an insuperable sadness.  After a traumatic event back in São Paulo, she and her best friend Almuta decide that it’s time to go off on their long-awaited travels around the world, ending up in the place they have always dreamed of visiting – Australia.  A chance encounter with an Aboriginal artist helps Alma to finally rid herself of the shadow which has haunted her for so long, and a chance part-time job over in Perth gives her the opportunity to become the one thing she is obsessed with – an angel…

Meanwhile, over in the Netherlands, literary critic Erik Zondag, a grumpy middle-aged scribbler, is off to an Austrian health farm to detox, hoping to shed not only a few kilos, but also some of the anger and frustration he feels.  In a high-class institution in the mountains, far from the eyes of the outside world, Erik begins to relax and let out the pent-up emotions he has been keeping inside – and then one morning…

…well, that would be telling 😉

When I started reading Lost Paradise, I had my doubts.  The first, introductory, section really grated: the narrator was pompous, the language stilted, the behaviour slightly arrogant and sexist… and it’s meant to be.  It’s actually the writer himself, introducing his main character personally (literally!).  Once we get into Alma’s story, the tone changes, swapping the irreverent tone for an excellent lyrical stretch of writing.  My favourite part of the book was the seventy-five pages that made up this section, a tale which probably could – and should – have been a (longish) short story in its own right.

The idea behind the book is a simple one, and the title, as you would expect, gives the reader a clue to this.  It is the idea of a yearning for something else, a simpler time, an escape from modern life – and a deliberate reference to Milton’s Paradise Lost (a book which is both seen and quoted from in Nooteboom’s work).  Both Alma and Erik are looking for something that isn’t really there; Erik tries to alleviate his ennui in the isolated Austrian mountains, and Alma wants to leave her Weltschmerz behind in the ancient Australian Outback.  As a man Alma meets remarks, this is something that many people are desperate to do:

“For people coming from a place of chaos and confusion, it’s quite tempting.  Especially since it has been destroyed, or almost.  That is what everyone has always been looking for, isn’t it?  A lost paradise?” p.51, Harvill Secker (2007)

It is a yearning for simplicity, for simpler times, that leads us to run away, looking for our own lost paradise…

There’s a lot to like in Lost Paradise, but there are also plenty of things which don’t quite work.  As an Australia (of sorts), I’m a little uneasy with the way the writer has used the Aboriginal people and ideas in the novella, playing with this idea of mysticism and exoticism.  He never attempts to really portray the culture beyond the surface clichés, and while this may be deliberate, it often feels… well, just wrong.

I’m also less than convinced by the meta-fictional elements, with the writer lusting after, and eventually speaking to, his young female creation.  Zondag’s story also suffers from this, with many a nod and a wink to Nooteboom’s fellow Dutch writers.  At one point, as Erik’s girlfriend condemns his over-savage critiques of certain works, he says:

“There was no question of making love after that.  Dutch authors had a lot to answer for.” p.84 

In fact, if you had no idea of any Dutch authors, a couple of hours in the company of Lost Paradise would be a great place to start learning more 😉

In the end, I was left with the feeling that while Nooteboom is a talented writer, Lost Paradise is a slight, experimental, flawed work.  I’ve heard that he has written some good short-story collections, and this book almost feels like a couple of short stories extended and blended into something which doesn’t quite come off.  I love the writing (for the most part), and I think Susan Massotty’s translation is excellent; it’s certainly very easy to see the different styles the writer originally used in the different sections.  However, if you’re looking for a masterpiece of Dutch literature, I think you would be best advised to try something a little more substantial.

Possibly by the same writer 😉

9 thoughts on “The Wings Of An Angel

  1. I know I read this book a couple of years ago, but I really don't remember much about it, except that I felt offended by his appropriation of Aboriginal culture, the whole “whitefella wheels out Aboriginal mysticism” thing, which never fails to make me want to throw things. I think you liked it a lot more than I did.


  2. Violet – From that angle, there is a lot not to like, but I did enjoy the writing in that section of the book. Overall, I found it a bit too clever, a bit too crass in its meta-fictional showing off, but I'd like to try another of his as I think he can write well.


  3. I ve not read this one by him I was lucky to get a interview with him last year he is probably greatest living dutch writer ,I like way he tackles so many styles of book the last I read by him is the foxes short stories book and it is very different to the sound of this one ,all the best stu


  4. Stu – I've read a few good reviews of that one, so that would probably be my next stop. I suppose at his age it makes sense that he writes what he wants in a variety of styles 🙂


  5. I can't help but feel divided about the short stories I have read by Cees Nooteboom. I appreciate his style, and his at times unbelievably beautiful prose. But then, at the same time, I often feel a little at a loss on what to think of his stories (though he does have quite a few great ones exempt from this phenomena), and some of travel stories made me feel similarly uneasy about the exoticism: was I noticing exoticism, or cleverly used topos that might actually critique it? It still made me feel uncomfortable though.

    I'm actually looking forward to one of Nooteboom's novels (perhaps I will read it sometime next year?), which is considered his “classic”: Rituals.

    I can see how this one might not work for every reader though. I don't think I will read it any time soon, having read your and Violet's opinions.


  6. Hello Tony: I have one of this author's books on my shelf from last year's Dutch-readalong which I didn't participate in. Can't remember the title now, but I'm hoping that it's not this one as it sounds like a mixed bag.


  7. Iris – He's definitely an author I'd like to try again, so thanks for the tip on 'Rituals' – it's probably best to judge a writer on his best work, not a random library choice 😉

    Guy – It is a bit. Hopefully, your choice will be a good one 🙂


  8. Tony, I can only agree with you, while I managed to enjoy it, it's incredibly flawed. If it had been my first, that might have been it.
    Don't give up on him just yet.
    Rutals is a wonderful book and some of the shorter ones like Mokusei! are as well.


Every comment left on my blog helps a fairy find its wings, so please be generous - do it for the fairies.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.