‘Snakes and Earrings’ by Hitomi Kanehara (Review)

I was hoping to have time for one more J-Lit post before leaving the first month of JLC7only just though, so it’ll have to be a quick one. didn’t quite make it 😉  Luckily (once again!), I just happened to have the perfect book hanging around on the shelves.  I have to say though that it’s not one for the faint-hearted…

Snakes and Earrings (translated by David James Karashima) is the debut work of Hitomi Kanehara, one which won her the prestigious Akutagawa Prize in 2004, at the age of just nineteen.  Like many Akutagawa-Prize winning works, it’s a fairly short piece, clocking in at a rather spaced-out 118 pages, and it’s one that seems designed to be sped through.

It’s the story of Lui, a nineteen-year-old woman enjoying life on the Tokyo night scene.  Her life changes when she gets together with Ama, a man with a slightly unusual appearance.  It’s not his red hair, his tattoos or his piercings which attract Lui though – it’s the fact that his tongue has been split in two, like a snake’s…

Initially hesitant to commit to Ama’s world, Lui quickly gives in to her curiosity, and soon she is on her own path to a snake’s tongue.  Shiba-san, the owner of the tattoo parlour where she gets her initial studs, also talks her into getting a tattoo on her back, and it isn’t long before she senses that the tattoo artist has his eye on her as well.  Can Lui cope in this new world?  And just who has the forked tongue around here?

Snakes and Earrings is an interesting look at a sub-culture which, to put it mildly, I’m unlikely to ever get close to in real life.  Lui acts as the reader’s introduction into a world which, behind its facade, is actually fairly ordinary.  Our initial view of Ama as a bit of a weirdo is softened by our repeated views of his domestic life, his appearance hiding the fact that he’s just a normal bloke:

“He wasn’t bad-looking.  I mean, all right, his eyes do have a kind of constant menacing stare that can be uncomfortable, but in general I’d still say he falls into the good-looking category.  Still, with the tattoo and a face full of piercings, I guess it was difficult to really tell if he looked good or bad.”
p.49 (Vintage Originals, 2005)

In fact, Ama is a tricky character to pin down.  At times, he definitely lives up to the image his cosmetic alterations suggest…

The theme of not judging a book by its cover is an important one in Snakes and Earrings.  Every character we meet has their flaws, and it is up to the reader to give them enough time to discover whether those flaws are skin deep, or whether they go closer to the core.  This is as true for Lui as it is for the men she hangs around.  A bored freeter, one of the new generation who won’t commit to a restrictive work life, Lui spends her days drinking, waiting for Ama to get home from work, and her nights having sex or doing the odd spot of casual entertaining.

In fact, Lui comes to be the character we feel most sympathy for.  Although she doesn’t really have any problems, neither does she have anything to live for.  It’s going to take something special to snap her out of her downward spiral, a wake-up call.  We’re just not sure what that wake-up call will be…

Snakes and Earrings is a smooth, polished, quick read, and David James Karashima’s translation is a good one (certainly, nothing really stood out at all – which is always a good sign!).  Despite this though, it’s a book I liked, rather than loved.  It all seems a bit like a tame attempt to shock, as if the mere mention of split tongues and giant tattoos is enough to warrant being given the Akutagawa Prize.  In fact, when you hear that Kanehara was one of two winners on that occasion, the other being Risa Wataya, another nineteen-year-old, you begin to suspect that the judges were focusing just as much on the writer as on the story (some cruel souls – including me – have speculated that the caricature Fuka-Eri in Murakami’s 1Q84 is a hybrid of Kanehara and Wataya…).

Still, it’s an enjoyable read with a twist in the tale and slightly more to recommend it than may appear at first glance.  And if you do like it, Autofiction, Kaneharas’ only other work to have been translated into English, is even better.  It’s just as messed up though 🙂


10 thoughts on “‘Snakes and Earrings’ by Hitomi Kanehara (Review)

  1. This sounds absolutely fascinating to me. Aren't the Japanese adept at writing of the macabre? Also, I'm curious if the snake-like is representative of Satan…I want to read this.


  2. I have had this on my TBR shelves for several years. It's so small I keep telling myself that I can squeeze it in, but somehow the weeks, months and years pass. It looked intriguing when I picked it up … now I should pick it up again.


  3. Bellezza – I'm not sure if it's a Japanese trait or just an aspect of the literary scene that publishers like to translate. Unfortunately, our understanding of the culture is very much shaped by what they choose to bring out – and what they think will sell…


  4. You perfectly summed up my sense of this book: “a tame attempt to shock.” I just found it so dull, especially in comparison to Ryu Murakami's stuff–which I also don't like, but also can't forget. I know I read “Snakes and Earrings” but I remember almost nothing about it.


  5. Colleen – I haven't read too much of R. Murakami's work, but it'd be hard to live up to that 😉 This is an entertaining story, but certainly nothing special. It's a clear example of a convenient book fitting a market and a perspective (the imprint is Vintage Originals…). On a slight tangent, I do feel that the Akutagawa Prize is a bit of a strange one in that it favours short works and is awarded to unknowns – perhaps it's not the best guide to literary excellence…


Every comment left on my blog helps a fairy find its wings, so please be generous - do it for the fairies.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.