‘The Girl from the Coast’ by Pramoedya Ananta Toer (Review)

IMG_5356When starting out on my adventures in Indonesian literature, as is the case when I start reading more widely from any country or culture, I was on the look out for any must-read authors, and one name which cropped up repeatedly was Pramoedya Ananta Toer.  The author of the famed Buru Quartet, he spent years in prison for his opposition to the Soeharto regime, and before his death he was often mentioned as a potential Nobel-Prize winner.  Today, then, I’m looking at one of his other famous books, a tale of long ago, and a story closer to the writer himself than you might expect…

The Girl from the Coast (translated by Willem Samuels) introduces a beautiful fourteen-year-old girl living in a coastal fishing village.  Rumours about her looks reach an important official in the nearby city, and before too long a marriage has been arranged, the girl being whisked from her comfortable existence to land in a new world.  Suddenly, she is the mistress of a large house with servants, freed from the burden of labour and overwhelmed with fine clothes and jewellery.

Despite the wonders of her new life, the girl struggles to adapt.  Her husband is kind, but rarely at home.  She can enjoy the expanses of the house and gardens, with servants to do her bidding, yet in truth she has no freedom, or permission to leave the compound.  The girl forces herself to accept that her status in life has changed, trying to become the wife she is told she must be.  However, there’s always the secret wish to leave it all behind and head back to the coast…

Toer’s novel is very much a work of historical fiction, albeit one based on the true life story of the writer’s grandmother.  Set in the Dutch colonial period, it gives a fascinating glimpse into a distant (and for many readers) alien past, but we’re not the only ones suffering from culture shock – the move from the seaside shack to a city residence has the girl reeling.  Quite apart from the novelties of cushions and electricity, she senses a more telling change in herself:

As the girl looked in the mirror, watching as the servant continued her ministrations, she saw her face changing little by little, until finally she didn’t recognize herself at all.
When the servant finished and stepped aside, the girl stared in the mirror and whispered, “Is that me?”
“You’re very beautiful,” the servant sighed.
This was the beginning, the girl thought.  This was to be her future world.
p.23 (Hyperion East, 2002)

This change of face brings about a realisation of the vast gulf between the two existences and cements her determination to make the best of the new role.

In truth, though, her newly found status is more fragile than she realises, and gradually we see glimpses of a darker future.  We can’t help but notice the children running around the house from time to time (and wonder whose they might be).  The girl’s servant begins to talk about previous mistresses, bringing the girl to eventually understand that she is not a real wife.  Even when her husband allows her to visit her home village, there’s no respite from her new life.  The way people see her has changed, their behaviour even more so – as friends, relatives and even her parents bow and scrape to her, the girl realises that if her new life implodes one day, she won’t be able to come back.

The Girl from the Coast is a moving tale focusing on injustice and the imbalance which existed (and exists) in society.  In addition to examining the plight of women (forced to marry without having a say in the matter, having to serve their new ‘master’), Toer is particularly interested in the fate of the poor.  In a society which still resembles a feudal system, quite apart from the awful living standards and the constant presence of death, the poor are treated like animals by their fellow citizens:

“Listen to me, Mardinah.  I lived in the city for two years before you came along, but it’s only now that I realize what city people, people of the noble class, fear the most – it is to not be respected.  And yet, you’re all so afraid of showing even a little respect toward people from the coast.” (p.155)

The girl’s words ring true.  Mardinah, a distant relative of the girls’ husband, turns out to be a rather unpleasant character, sent to make the girl see that she doesn’t belong (as if the girl wasn’t aware of that already…).

The novel isn’t perfect, and at times I found it a little melodramatic.  It’s at its best when following the girl’s psychological development, showing a young woman growing up quickly, forced to think through every decision with nobody to guide her along.  It would have been interesting to see her grow further, which makes the five-page epilogue, compressing the events of decades into a few sentences rather puzzling…

…until, that is, you read the footnote in which Samuels explains what happened to the later adventures:

The Girl from the Coast was originally intended as the first volume in a trilogy of novels on the growth of the nationalist movement in Indonesia, with the story line based loosely on the life history of the author’s family.  Because the other two novels in the trilogy were destroyed by the Indonesian military, this epilogue, which was not part of the original novel, was prepared by the author and translator specifically for the publication of this English-language edition in order to provide readers a greater sense of closure to the tale. (p.275)

All of which makes me feel a little guilty for daring to criticise the book…

The Girl from the Coast is an interesting novel, especially for those interested in Indonesian history, and while it’s far from perfect, there’s enough here to make me want to try more of Toer’s work.  The next step, of course, would be to seek out the first part of The Buru Quartet, a series written (mentally) while the writer was in prison.  I suspect that it’s a work which will provide even more of an insight into Indonesia’s turbulent past…

18 thoughts on “‘The Girl from the Coast’ by Pramoedya Ananta Toer (Review)

  1. Fascinating – this is a culture I know nothing of and the girl’s fate sounds chilling. I’ll look forward to hearing what you think of any more of his books you read.


  2. Hi Tony, now that you have read one of Toers books, I’m curious to know what you’ll find of “The Buru quartet”. For me that’s one of the top-ten novels I’ve read. Greetings, Erik


    1. Stu – Well, you’d think that after Frankfurt, there might be even more over the next couple of years. Here’s hoping that more gets translated.


  3. It is very interesting book. It is very melodramatic, but it is sadly based on a true story. I can put more feelings into when I read it because I am from the culture. The Buru Quartet is a wonderful series too. Thanks for the review.


  4. I loved this review, Tony. Since I lived a few years in Indonesia, I am very attached to this wonderful place and its people and read also quite a lot of Indonesian literature. Toer is of course the giant of indonesian literature and the Buru Quartet is a must for everyone that wants to understand the country’s turbulent past. I can recommend also The Mute’s Soliloquy, a book about his time in the Indonesian version of the Gulag Archipelago, and a small book Exile, an interview with him that adds a lot to the understanding of his work. The work you reviewed is still unknown to me but now I want to read it also.


    1. Thomas – ‘The Mute’s Soliloquy’ is a possibility as our library has a copy of that; unfortunately, none of the Buru Quartet books are available 😦


  5. Thanks for this great and honest review! To be honest, I’ve never finished an Indonesian (original) version of this novel due to its (as you said) melodramatic plot (maybe because it is based on actual story of Toer’s grandmother). But after I read this review, I’d love to take a look to this novel again.

    If you enjoy this book, The Buru Quartet will surely satisfy your curiosity towards Indonesian culture and literary works, especially related to Dutch colonial era in Indonesia. FYI, The Buru Quartet English versions were published by Penguin Books, so it should be not so hard to find on Amazon or Barnes and Noble.


    1. Abighifari – It is a little melodramatic, but there’s still a lot to like – and I hope to get to the Buru books at some point 🙂


  6. Don’t mean to add to the drumbeat on the Buru Quartet. I’m a professor of Southeast Asian studies, and I wholeheartedly agree that Buru is worthwhile. However, the quartet truly is a single work whose pleasures build over a very long time– somewhat like the experience of attending an all-night wayang shadow puppet performance, to pick an analogy close to Pram’s heart. This Earth of Mankind can seem a bit flat and even tedious at points, but the culmination is quite memorable. And the story continues over the next three books in a manner that simply builds and deepens and is ultimately quite satisfying. And then when one considers the manner of its composition (Pram’s home and research destroyed by the death squads and then reconstructing his massive tetralogy as oral literature in a prison colony), it’s nothing short of astonishing. But the actual reading of Buru Quartet does take patience. Thank you, Tony, for all your generous and insightful reviews of Indonesian literature so far!


    1. Evan – Thanks for that 🙂 I’d love to try more Indonesian literature (and ‘The Buru Quartet’ would certainly be at the top of my list) – if only I had more time (and there weren’t so many other books demanding my attention!).


Every comment left on my blog helps a fairy find its wings, so please be generous - do it for the fairies.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.