‘Like a Fading Shadow’ by Antonio Muñoz Molina (Review)

My last look at Spanish writer Antonio Muñoz Molina’s work took me to Lisbon, where the language differences I encountered were less due to the location than to the fact that I was reading the original version of the book.  Fortunately, my latest choice was in English, making for a less taxing experience, yet echoes of the last book remained.  You see, while this new release is a very different novel, the location is rather familiar, as we follow the writer back to Portugal, in the company of a rather surprising travel companion…

Like a Fading Shadow (translated by Camilo A. Ramirez, review copy courtesy of Tuskar Rock Press and Australian distributors Allen & Unwin) is a fascinating, hybrid work, with a historical event at its heart.  It focuses on ten days in 1968, when James Earl Ray (the man who shot Martin Luther King Jr.) was on the run in the Portuguese capital, desperately striving to receive a visa allowing him to escape to one of the country’s African colonies, where he would be able to disappear for good.  The writer examines Ray’s movements during those ten days in great detail, tracing his movements through Lisbon as he goes back and forth between his shabby hotel, various embassies and the odd bar (where he went to pick up prostitutes).

A work of historical fiction, then? Not entirely.  While Ray plays a major role in the book, there’s just as much here about Muñoz Molina himself.  The genesis of the work is the coincidence the writer feels at having discovered Ray’s stay in a city that played such an important part in his own life, and the chapters of Like A Fading Shadow initially alternate between the events of 1968 and those two decades later, when Muñoz Molina is struggling to write his novel Winter in Lisbon.  But is there anything other than the city of Lisbon connecting these two stories?  Well, that would be telling 😉

Muñoz Molina is an excellent writer, and this book was a pleasure to read.  Ramirez has done excellent work here, with the writer recognisable as the one translated by Edith Grossman and Esther Allen in earlier books.  A mix of memoir and fiction, historical reportage and speculation, Like a Fading Shadow is written using a variety of styles and perspectives.  At times, the reader is encouraged to follow events through Ray’s eyes, while at others we are pulled back to Muñoz Molina’s viewpoint.  There’s a difference too in how the information is conveyed, the clipped sentences when dealing with facts giving way to longer, conjectural sentences when the writer delves into speculation, with many examples of ‘I wonder how…’ or ‘He must have…’ peppering the text.

There’s a strange fascination to be had in following Ray through Lisbon.  Muñoz Molina describes lengthy rambles through the city, in which Ray does his best to avoid attention, hoping to fade into the background:

Hiding in his hotel room during the day and walking through the streets of Cais do Sodré at night – he could not tell if he had managed to become truly invisible, to vanish like a fading shadow, like a gangster from a movie who can just get plastic surgery and all of a sudden look like Humphrey Bogart, or Ernst Stavro Blofeld, the supreme villain from James Bond, who can be fat, pale and bald in one novel, and slender, tan, with white hair in another.
p.135 (Tuskar Rock Press, 2017)

The writer painstakingly describes Ray’s efforts to blend in, including his nondescript clothes and the habit of never looking anyone in the eye.  Time and again, the writer provides accounts of eye-witnesses who struggle to remember the American’s appearance the moment he leaves the room; it’s unsurprising that he stayed free for so long, even with the whole FBI on his trail.

The ten days Ray spent in Lisbon make for an excellent subject for a book, so it may come as a surprise to find that Like a Fading Shadow is just as much (if not more so) about Muñoz Molina than the fugitive.  The writer’s chapters are mostly set in the late eighties, describing a bored civil servant (c.f. In Her Absence…) and his struggles to make progress on the novel he’s writing.  We learn of his double life as a worker and family man, and a night owl immersing himself in the world of the arts (and suffering through the hangover at work the next day).  There’s a difficulty in balancing the two contradictory existences, particularly when his wife and son, who live in another city, come to visit.  It’s then that he feels the frustration of the selfish writer, having to go on family walks and dinners when all he wants to do is shut himself up in his study and work on his novel in the midst of cigarette smoke and whiskey fumes.

I remember Winter in Lisbon very clearly, so for me the writer’s description of how the novel came together was probably the highlight of this book.  He discusses how he decided on the themes and the way in which the characters of the book were drawn from real life, based on people he met, places he’d once visited.  Initially, he finds himself unable to bring all the elements together, until, that is, he realises the mistakes he’s been making:

But I was not hiding: there were simply things that I did not know or that did not matter for the story, and my mistake, all that time, had been to try to fill every gap with unnecessary details, fill all the space in the story like a mediocre painter fills a whole canvas with paint or a pretentious musician leaves no space for silence.  I was now sketching the characters mostly through the missing details, and the story was unfolding before me like a series of flashes or quick strokes in a vast blank space. (pp.38/9)

He manages to write the first half of the story, but then hits a sudden roadblock, unable to continue.  There’s only one way to get the story moving again, and that’s by going off to Lisbon to see the setting of the novel for himself.  The fact that his wife has just given birth to their second son is a minor detail…

While this mixture of stories may sound a little confused and disjointed, somehow it’s anything but.  The writer manages to carefully alternate between the two strands, drawing parallels between the visits to Lisbon and eventually expanding his scope.  We learn more about Ray and his back story, circling around the fateful events of April the 4th, 1968, with the tension gradually building as the inevitability of his capture begins to sink in.  Later, new elements are introduced, such as the writer’s later visit to Lisbon (to research *this* novel) and even, towards the very end, a section taking us to the Memphis balcony where a tired man is about to meet his fate.

Like a Fading Shadow is  wonderful book, absorbing and thought-provoking, whether your interest lies in the description of a world-famous killer or the self-justifying claims of a writer intent on finishing his book, whatever the cost.  However, if there’s one minor nagging doubt I have about the book (and it’s one I’m sure most readers would have), it’s the feeling that there are two stories being told here, and the success of the novel hangs on how well the writer manages to integrate them.  Is the book a coherent whole, or is there a slight sense that the structure is a tad forced?  Certainly, the final sections focusing on King and the late revelations about Muñoz Molina’s private life do help to tie the ideas together more tightly, but a critical reader may well decide that the writer never quite manages to bring the two main ideas together sufficiently.

Still, that’s a minor criticism, and one for another day.  Like a Fading Shadow manages to be informative, enjoyable and thoroughly absorbing – another excellent work from the Spanish writer.  Towards the end of the novel, I felt a little sad that the book had to end, but as the writer explains, that’s the way it has to be, even if real life works differently:

But in real life, the future lasts forever and real-life stories end by disintegrating into others, dispersing, unraveling loose threads without a clear plot that intertwines with other stories and ends up traveling far from their starting point.  They resemble African or Asian musical compositions in their open form, the way they’re prolonged without fatigue and significant variation for hours, days, nights, flowing like rivers, without a sequence or beginning or end. (p.230)

Life goes on after the end of the novel, for both Ray (until his death in prison) and especially Muñoz Molina, and I defy anyone who reaches the end of the book not to immediately start looking for more information about the two men.  You see, the thing with stories is that’s always more to learn about them, particularly when they’re as fascinating as this one…

4 thoughts on “‘Like a Fading Shadow’ by Antonio Muñoz Molina (Review)

  1. Just starting this.

    Interesting that you comment; “I remember Winter in Lisbon very clearly, so for me the writer’s description of how the novel came together was probably the highlight of this book”

    I have read 4 previous novels by the author – but unfortunately not that one! And it also seems to be rather hard to get hold of.


    1. Paul – No, it seems it’s hard to get hold of, so I was lucky enough to get a Spanish-language copy from the local library. I wouldn’t say it’s his best work, but there’s a lot to like, a moody, atmospheric thriller with some excellent writing 🙂


  2. Like you I recently read El invierno in Lisboa in the original recently and really enjoyed the atmosphere and mystery. I certainly could be tempted to continue with Like a fading shadow although, having read your review of In the night of time, I might also go for that (in translation for comfort of reading’s sake).


    1. Passage à l’Est! – ‘In the Night of Time’ is an excellent reading experience, but I think AMM is a writer whose books you can safely try without being too disappointed 🙂


Every comment left on my blog helps a fairy find its wings, so please be generous - do it for the fairies.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.