‘The Secret History of the Lord of Musashi’ & ‘Arrowroot’ by Jun’ichirō Tanizaki (Review)

It’s been an interesting few months, but all good things must come to an end, and my spell of reading the work of Jun’ichirō Tanizaki is no exception. While I haven’t quite finished everything translated into English, I think now is a good time to finish off, particularly with Man Booker International Prize obligations just around the corner.  However, I do have one last review, a tenth consecutive #TanizakiThurs post to round off the series, and I’m rather tempted to say that I’ve saved the best for last…

The books I’ve read over the past few months have explored several of Tanizaki’s favourite themes (such as erotica and the influence of the west), but one important focus, a fascination with the past, hasn’t really come up.  Today’s choice, though, remedies that omission, featuring a couple of works where the writer blends fact with fiction in using old tales to create intriguing glimpses of his country’s history.  The longer piece, The Secret History of the Lord of Musashi, is an impressive novella recounting events from the sixteenth century, and it’s supplemented here by Arrowroot, a shorter tale set at the start of the twentieth century (both translated by Anthony H. Chambers).  The two works are different in tone, but what connects them is the style of writing and their use of ‘historical’ sources to pull the story along.

Arrowroot is a gentle account of a journey the narrator took to Yoshino, a famous sightseeing area in Nara Prefecture, some twenty years before the telling of the story.  Seeking inspiration for a novel, he decides to follow in the footsteps of some historical (and mythical) figures along an almost inaccessible river.  Long intrigued by the history of the ‘Southern court’ (with its own rebel Emperor), he hopes his visit to the area will bear literary fruit.

Setting off on his journey with an old friend, Tsumura, he soon finds that he’s not the only one with a reason for heading out into the countryside.  Tsumura reveals that he’s been this way once before, and he’s making the return journey with a very special purpose, namely to see if a certain woman might look fondly upon him.  This, then, is a story within a story, as the young man retraces the path of his ancestors to look for love and the place his ancestors came from.

Arrowroot is an unhurried tale, as much about the journey and setting as any idea of plot, and many readers will enjoy the languid pace and descriptions, just as the narrator does:

As I listened to this account, I gazed at the pearl of dew in my hand.  It was as though the mystery and the sunshine of the mountains had congealed on my palm.  I have heard that country people visiting the capital used to take packets of soil home with them as mementos: and if someone were to ask me about the color of the autumn at Yoshino, I think I would take some of these persimmons home to show.
‘Arrowroot’, p.149 (Vintage Books, 2001)

There are several nods to the writer’s other works here, with the descriptions of traditional paper production reminiscent of Tanizaki’s ideas from In Praise of Shadows and the fascination with traditional plays reminding the reader of young Jun’ichirō’s formative years in Childhood Years: A Memoir.  However, even if you’re not a Tanizaki expert, Arrowroot can simply be read as a charming love story with a traditional setting, one where you could almost forget what century you’re in.

However, as entertaining as Arrowroot is, it’s merely a side dish to the main course, The Secret History of the Lord of Musashi, which I’ll allow the writer to introduce himself:

This volume tells the story of the Lord of Musashi, born in the sixteenth-century Period of Civil Wars and known everywhere for his cunning and strength.  He was the boldest, cruelest leader of his age.  But those close to him said that he had masochistic sexual desires.  Could this be true?
‘The Lord of Musashi’, p.9

Well, I’ll discuss that a little below, but let’s just make it clear now that if anything that is a massive understatement…

The story is told by an unnamed writer who draws on two historical sources to bring the figure of the fearsome lord to life, and it begins with a portrait of the sexual deviant as a young man, living as a hostage at the castle of a major clan.  During a lengthy siege, he manages to see a young woman cleaning the heads of the enemy notables, and when she explains why one of them is different from the rest (and when he sees how lovingly she tends to it…), the young Hōshimaru decides to please her by finding another head himself – and having a momentous impact on the siege while he’s at it.

Years later, having come of age and taken the new name of Terukatsu, the future lord finds a new obsession in the form of a married noblewoman, and once again it all has to do with a particular fetish.  The woman has a secret, and Terukatsu is only too happy to help her, even if he has to betray those close to him in the process.  As his influence grows, so does his need for excitement, leading him to act out his desires in some rather unusual ways.  Woe betide those who get in his way – or even those who seek to please him…

The Secret History… is a wonderful story, a prime example of Tanizaki’s historical stories with the sexual twists of his contemporary work thrown in.  The writer is concerned with producing a portrait of the aggressive warrior, poring over the (fictional) documents in search of hints of inner turmoil and conflict.  At times, Tanizaki produces a tense narrative drawing the reader on, while elsewhere he turns instead to carefully weighing up his sources.  He puts forward the old flowery language of the texts – and then mocks it:

She is described in ‘The Dream of a Night’:
Being a wellborn lady from the capital, she knew the ways of poetry and music; nor even Yang Kuei-fei of far Cathay or Princess Sotoori of our own land could have matched the pearl beauty of her petal eyebrows and rosy lips…
This string of clichés does not make clear how beautiful she may actually have been.
‘The Secret History of the Lord of Musashi’, p.53

However, he soon gets back to the action, and there’s certainly a lot to get through.  An enthralling tale of history, bloody battles and base betrayal, The Secret History… also steps behind the historical curtain to show us what one of these adrenalin-charged warriors got up to in private, with scenes that are equally as amusing as they can be twisted.

Chambers’ introduction discusses how these two stories kicked off Tanizaki’s interest in historical fiction, and with a couple of others on the shelf, I’m very tempted to keep going.  However, they’ll have to keep for another day – it’s time to bring the Tanizaki reading marathon to an end.  Hopefully, I’ve managed to bring a few of his books to a wider audience over the past few months and persuaded a few of my readers to give some of them a go.  Reading the works of an author over a relatively short period of time has been an interesting experience, and one I’d like to repeat in the future with another writer.  The question, of course, is who – but I’ll leave that for another day 🙂

4 thoughts on “‘The Secret History of the Lord of Musashi’ & ‘Arrowroot’ by Jun’ichirō Tanizaki (Review)

  1. I will definitely miss your #TanizakiThurs posts, but I’m looking forward to the Man Booker International Prize as well so I can’t complain. As for another writer whose works you could marathon in the future, what about Abe Kobo? 🙂


    1. Akylina – I have to say Abe’s not my favourite Japanese writer… I think Kawabata is more likely, or possibly a broader scope targeting female writers 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Whoever you end up choosing I’m sure it’ll be interesting 🙂 (female writers is such a good idea, they are never spoken about much with a couple of famous exeptions)


Every comment left on my blog helps a fairy find its wings, so please be generous - do it for the fairies.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.